Navigate

Six Pro-Palestinian Protesters Settle Cases

Defense attorney Gina Balamucki ’13 (’21 JD) argued that the encampment set up by the protesters was protected by the First Amendment and those cited were exercising a constitutional right to protest in a public space. (Photo: Carolina Alumni/ CoryDinkel)

Six protesters arrested in April during the pro-Palestinian encampment on campus had their charges dismissed Friday in Orange County District Court, The News and Observer reported.

Defense attorney Gina Balamucki ’13 (’21 JD) argued that the encampment set up by the protesters was protected by the First Amendment and those cited were exercising a constitutional right to protest in a public space. She denied the defendants disrupted campus activities and said the University acknowledged the quad was “a public forum open to all.”

“We really hope that this will help teach universities what is actually required to stop student protestors carrying out protests and acts of free speech,” Balamucki told WRAL.

Nineteen people so far have accepted deferred prosecutions and six have accepted conditional discharges. Under both arrangements, the defendants will have their cases officially dismissed upon meeting certain conditions, such as community service.

Charles Soeder ’08, a research technician at Carolina, was the first protester to not take a plea deal and was tried in court Friday, where Orange County District Court Judge Samantha Cabe ’02 (JD) dismissed his charges. Five others accepted plea bargains. District Attorney Jeff Nieman told WRAL that his office last week dismissed charges against the protesters because his office could not identify or locate the charging officers, many of whom were from other UNC System campus police forces.

Soeder’s dismissal at trial implies a judge may dismiss the charges against the remaining defendants.

Thirty-six people were cited April 30 with trespassing or arrested on additional charges when UNC administrators ordered the breakup of the encampment on Polk Place outside South Building, The News and Observer reported. At least 13 were current or former Carolina students.

Eight cases remain pending. Some will be heard Friday and the remaining will be heard in early January.

Share via: