Shock.
Sorrow. Embarrassment. Anger. Surprise.Those words reflect many of the alumni reactions to the dual investigations into Carolina’s football program — one dealing with possible agent violations and the other with possible academic misconduct.

Douglas S. Dibbert ’70
As a charter member of the Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics — from its first meeting in 1989 and throughout the meetings that shaped its inaugural 1991 report and subsequent reports in 1992, 1993 and 2001 — I reminded colleagues that “not all fans are alumni, and not all alumni are fans.” Alumni care more about preserving and enhancing the value of our diplomas than boasting about our school’s athletic achievements. I urged that all decisions regarding intercollegiate athletics be based on what is best for the student-athletes. And I noted that several constituencies must contribute to achieve meaningful and necessary reform — college presidents, university governing boards, faculty, athletics directors, coaches, alumni, student-athletes, secondary school officials and the NCAA.
Difficult times prompt alumni to value university leadership that is firmly committed to preserving academic integrity. Chancellor Holden Thorp ’86 began his remarks at the Aug. 26 news conference by saying: “To everyone out there who loves this University, I’m sorry for what I have to tell you.” He went on to affirm, “It’s a privilege to put on the North Carolina uniform and to represent this University, and it’s our job to make sure that the people who do so have earned that privilege.” He concluded: “We will find out what happened. We will do everything we can to keep it from happening again. And we will not let these mistakes define our University and what we stand for. We will use this to be a better university, athletic department and football program in the years to come.”
Athletics Director Dick Baddour ’66 has stated that two principles are guiding the investigations:”One — we are going to protect the integrity of The University of North Carolina and place that integrity at the forefront of every decision we make; and two — we will be fair to our student-athletes.” Speaking about some members of the football team, Baddour said that “although some of them have made mistakes, they are our students, and we need to support them.”
The NCAA and University investigations have not concluded, but there are some who have reached their own judgments and have publicly suggested what measures they think should be taken. We all wish these issues could be resolved quickly, but as the chancellor has said, precipitous action is like “landing a plane without first seeing the runway.” A thorough, thoughtful review of all our compliance processes and procedures is under way. Just as Carolina faculty have been an important part of the investigation, faculty will help shape the needed changes. Carolina’s academic support program for student-athletes has long reported to the College of Arts and Sciences — not to athletics.
It is easy to support Carolina athletics when our teams are doing well, when teams are winning national championships, and when the entire program is consistently highly ranked in the annual Directors’ Cup competition. Now it is important that we support the football players who have worked so hard, violated no rules and are representing Carolina so well under difficult circumstances.
While Carolina alumni are disappointed and saddened by the investigations, we can be reassured by how our University is handling this unfortunate and embarrassing incident. Our response has been transparent, consistent with what the NCAA and federal law permits.We’re being careful to uncover anything and everything. Our faculty are fully engaged.We are accepting responsibility. We are not blaming others.
And we can be hopeful — hopeful that Carolina’s hard-earned reputation for integrity throughout our athletics program will, in time, be restored. We have 28 teams and nearly 800 student-athletes. The unfortunate decisions and actions by a few associated with one team should not diminish our support for Carolina and Carolina athletics — long known and respected for winning the right way — the Carolina Way.
Yours at Carolina,

Douglas S. Dibbert ’70
ONLINE: A detailed explanation of what can occur in a typical NCAA infractions case is available online at alumni.unc.edu/NCAA_step-by-step.