University administrators may record a class without the knowledge or permission of the class’s instructor in “rare” circumstances, under a new policy that went into effect in February.
The University may only secretly record classroom sessions when gathering evidence in connection with an investigation into alleged violations of University policy with the written authorization of the provost and the chief human resources officer, or for any lawful purpose with the written authorization of the provost and the University counsel in consultation with the chair of the faculty.
“I’ll immediately say that’s a pretty strong thing to be able to do, and that’s why I said it’s only done under rare circumstances,” Interim Provost Jim Dean told the faculty executive committee in February. “It almost always has something to do with some legal issue.”
The inclusion of the faculty chair was added after several professors expressed concerns around academic freedom. The chair is elected by voting members of the faculty rather than hired or appointed by University administration.
The policy includes several protections for faculty members, and students remain prohibited from recording classes, even online, without their instructor’s knowledge. Further, instructors will be notified seven days prior to a classroom recording for “regularly scheduled evaluations,” such as those used to grant tenure or promote a faculty member. Administrators must collaborate with the instructor to identify a class “that is representative of the overall course.” Instructors may record their own classes for educational purposes.
Many instructors began recording their lectures during the pandemic, when remote instruction made the practice beneficial for students. By the end of 2020, the University had equipped 137 general-purpose classrooms with cameras and microphones to support hybrid instruction.
In April 2024, the University made headlines when it used the cameras to record a business professor’s classroom sessions without his knowledge following reports concerning class content and conduct. The University did not renew his contract that summer and cited the state’s one-party consent law as justification for the recordings. The professor filed a lawsuit against the University and the Board of Governors in September that year, alleging his departure was retaliation “for his public criticisms of UNC’s recording of his classroom lectures,” according to the complaint, which remains unsettled.
A few months after the professor’s contract was not renewed, then-Provost Chris Clemens told the faculty executive committee he was developing a new policy on classroom recording. Several faculty groups provided feedback on the draft policy over the following year and a half, aiming to eliminate vague clauses that they believed could have chilling effects on freedom of expression in the classroom.
Faculty Chair Beth Moracco ’92 (MA, ’99 PhD) has told the faculty executive committee that, since the policy’s inception, some faculty members have experienced heightened anxiety around surveillance due in part to instances on campus and at other universities in the recent past. Last year, the conservative activist group Accuracy in Media secretly recorded employees at six public colleges across North Carolina, leading to the dismissals or resignations of several faculty and staff, including a dean and an assistant director at UNC-Charlotte. Last fall, a Texas A&M University professor was fired after a student recorded her lecture about gender identity in literature. Andrea Bohlman, a professor of music at UNC, told the committee in December that strangers had entered several of her colleagues’ classrooms to record professors.
Prior to the new policy, UNC lacked a formal, Universitywide rule governing when administrators could record classroom lectures. The Daily Tar Heel reported in January that the lack of a formal recording policy led some faculty members to self-censor. Michael Palm, a communications professor who leads the local chapter of the American Association of University Professors, told the newspaper, “My sense is that most faculty, at this point, just assume they’re being watched.”