Navigate

Lawsuit: UNC Unlawfully Banned Protestors from Campus

Three civil rights groups have sued the University, alleging it unlawfully banned pro-Palestinian protesters from campus and violated their rights to free speech and due process.

The lawsuit was filed Tuesday by the American Civil Liberties Union of North Carolina; Emancipate NC, a Durham-based nonprofit that says it works to end mass incarceration and structural racism; and Muslim Advocates, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit working to end anti-Muslim discrimination. The suit was filed on behalf of five demonstrators, including two UNC students, who participated in the campus encampment last April.

The plaintiffs include Laila Dames, a Duke University student; Kathryn Newman, a Meredith College alumna; Emily Rogers, a Duke professor; and Mathangi Mohanarajah and Anshu Shah, both students at UNC.

The lawsuit names as defendants several UNC administrators — including Chancellor Lee Roberts, UNC Police Chief Brian James, Dean of Students Desirée Rieckenberg and Vice Chancellor Amy Johnson — and several arresting police officers.

Police from UNC and several UNC System schools forcibly disbanded the encampment April 30, charging 36 protesters with trespassing, after the group refused administrators’ and law enforcement’s directives to disperse. Dames, Newman and Rogers were cited with second-degree trespassing, though charges against all 36 protesters were dropped. Mohanarajah was not charged, though she was suspended from classes at UNC “without a hearing,” the lawsuit states. These four plaintiffs remain banned from campus.

Shah, the fifth plaintiff, was not charged and did not face disciplinary action but “has been hesitant to exercise his First Amendment rights” since the encampment was disbanded, the lawsuit states.

The lawsuit says the protesters were banned from campus without due process. Police Chief James, who issued the bans, holds the sole authority over the appeals process, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit says the appeal process consisted of James meeting with the plaintiffs’ counsel to discuss whether James intended to uphold the bans. The bans for Dames, Newman and Rogers were upheld, although they are allowed to seek medical treatment at the emergency department of UNC Hospitals. Mohanarajah’s class suspension was lifted in October but she remains “partially banned from campus” and needs James’ permission to attend “campus-based activities, including classes, on a case-by-case basis.”

The lawsuit alleges the arrests were a violation of the plaintiffs’ “right to be free from excessive force by law enforcement.” The suit lists injuries that that some of the plaintiffs, including one who uses a cane, sustained during their arrests, such as a shoulder cartilage tear, bruising, lacerations and a concussion.

This level of “punitive” response “far outweighs the response to past protests involving other viewpoints,” Reem Subei, senior staff attorney for Muslim Advocates, said in a statement. The lawsuit lists the Silent Sam statue protests and the Vietnam War protests as examples. (No demonstrators were issued indefinite campus bans or criminal trespassing charges in those protests.)

ACLU of North Carolina staff attorney Ivy Johnson told The News and Observer that the administrators’ actions against the plaintiffs “run counter to the missions of higher education and the deep-rooted protections of the First Amendment.”

UNC spokesperson Kevin Best said in a statement to The N&O, “We are committed to upholding the rights and responsibilities of all members of our community and remain dedicated to fostering an inclusive and respectful environment.”

Share via: