Navigate

Universities Propose Model for F&A Research Funding

UNC Vice Chancellor for Research Penny Gordon-Larsen said the new model helps research universities create line items for each cost, making them more transparent to federal agencies. (Photo: Carolina Alumni/Cory Dinkel)

Academic research leaders across the country, including UNC Vice Chancellor for Research Penny Gordon-Larsen, have proposed a new financial model by which the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and other federal agencies could cover costs at large research campuses.

The model was created by the Joint Associations Group (JAG), a consortium of universities, medical colleges and philanthropic organizations. Gordon-Larsen was part of JAG’s small committee that over the past year worked with Congress, federal agencies and the Office of Management and Budget to provide a framework to address issues related to so-called indirect costs.

Also known as facilities and administration costs, or F&A, indirect costs include electricity, HVAC, water infrastructure, building maintenance, research animal quarters, IT support and security, federal compliance personnel and dozens of other expensive necessities large research enterprises require.

Gordon-Larsen said the new model helps research universities create line items for each cost, making them more transparent to federal agencies. “You can see exactly where the money is spent,” she said. F&A, in the new model, looks more like direct costs, which typically cover things such as lab equipment, supplies, personnel salaries and other costs directly associated with experiments conducted under the terms of a grant.

For decades, the F&A rate has been negotiated between each university and the federal government through a laborious — and expensive — annual process based on criteria specific to each research campus. But that process has historically drawn criticism, including from politicians, policymakers and even researchers themselves, because of its lack of transparency.

In February 2025, the NIH, under interim leadership at the time, issued a memo explaining it would drastically reduce the F&A rate to a standard amount across the country. No more negotiated rates. At UNC, that would have reduced federal spending on research by tens of millions of dollars, if not hundreds of millions, each year. At other universities, the hit would’ve been even harsher.  (See “Research Under Threat,” May/June 2025 Review).

The proposed decrease caused confusion and consternation across the country at the same time NIH was withholding payments for grants it had already approved. State attorneys general and universities, including North Carolina’s and UNC, sued the federal government, and the courts put a hold on the proposed F&A reductions. They never happened.

Grant dollars began trickling into lab coffers in late spring 2025, and by the end of the federal fiscal year in October 2025, the UNC School of Medicine — which receives the most federal research funding of any school at Carolina — had received $353 million from the NIH, a $4 million increase over the previous year, making it No. 5 in NIH funding among public schools of medicine.

The new JAG model is now part of a federal bill’s language that Gordon-Larsen said still needs to be negotiated and have its fine details hammered out. “That’s the next step,” she said. “That’s what should be happening in the coming months.” UNC’s federal affairs leadership is now working with other universities and Congress to get the new model approved.

Meanwhile, the academic research landscape is still fraught with peril. Last year, the Trump administration proposed a 40 percent reduction to the NIH budget. Gordon-Larsen said that proposal never passed through Congress, which has always been responsible for setting the NIH budget. But it might have passed, she said, if not for U.S. Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, whom Gordon-Larsen praised for battling against budget cuts. The NIH budget for fiscal year 2026 was $48.7 billion, an increase of $415 million from the previous budget. For the next fiscal year, the Trump administration has proposed a 12.3 percent cut to the NIH budget. Congress has yet to approve the 2027 budget.

—Mark Derewicz

Share via: