April 1, 1994, was a big day for Joey Roman and the Zeigletics toilet company.
On internet message boards, he crowed, “Zeigletics (ZEIG.H) trades on the Halifax Canadian Exchange at $0.37 x $0.39 — a HUGE bargain!” Roman didn’t stop there, pointing out Zeigletics sponsored the Sudanese equivalent of the Boston Marathon; hundreds of fans waved plungers at the finish line.
“You gotta get in on this thing right NOW,” he posted. “The Canadians don’t even know about it yet! This company is an overnight Canadian success story … Hurry! Hot, Hot, Hot! Sizzle. Hotter than an egg on the roof of my new Porsche in mid-August.”
Roman’s claims seemed too good to be true, a textbook example of fraud. That’s exactly what he was. David Gardner ’88 created Roman as a representation of online message board scams back in the early 1990s, capitalizing on his writerly flair, sense of humor, financial acumen and the new frontier of the internet.
Three decades later, Gardner remains Roman’s antithesis as a co-founder of The Motley Fool, a financial advice company that popularized long-term stock investing through articles, newsletters, books and eventually podcasts.
Taking stock
As a seemingly Ivy League-bound prep-schooler from Washington, D.C., in the mid-1980s, Gardner was lured to Carolina by the Morehead Scholarship, a merit-based full ride that includes leadership development and mentorship. He majored in English and creative writing and learned from renowned professors Doris Betts ’54, Darryl J. Gless and Ken Reckford, to name a few. As college progressed, Gardner learned to combine his acquired love for writing with a long-held curiosity about the stock market, a trait borrowed from his father, a banking lawyer.
“I think one of the benefits of a humanities education is that you end up going, ‘OK, I know a little bit about a lot of different things,’ ” Gardner said. “That is what enabled me and inspired me to pick up something that seemingly was not part of my background.”
Gardner graduated with a love for the written word, but a less-than-ideal understanding of the financial world. He picked up the book How to Read a Financial Report and was off to the races … or at least to the message boards on AOL and Prodigy, where young Gardner began making waves giving financial advice.
Before that fateful April Fool’s Day in 1994, Gardner had left his job writing for Louis Rukeyser’s Wall Street newsletter to found The Motley Fool print newsletter, working full time with his brother Tom, an entrepreneur and financial writer, and Erik Rydholm, who would later become an influential television producer at ESPN. Thanks to a writeup in The Wall Street Journal, prompted by Gardner’s Carolina and Morehead connection with Alan Murray ’77, the Roman prank soon hit mainstream media.
In a WSJ article three weeks after the prank, reporter Christi Harlan wrote, “To Mr. Gardner’s amazement, some Prodigy users began clamoring for more information. Once they figured out he was making it up, the messages got ugly, but not as ugly as the ones from the hypesters he was making fun of. ‘You may think you can hide behind your keyboard. … Take care. … [t]he world can be a real unsafe environment,’ said one.”
Articles in the Chicago Tribune, The New Yorker and elsewhere followed. It was clear The Motley Fool wasn’t going anywhere anytime soon. Gardner didn’t expect any of it to happen.
“This newsletter with our funny name that I pulled from Shakespeare, inspired in part by my Carolina class with Dr. Gless, would now be printed in The Wall Street Journal,” Gardner cackled. “It’s hilarious.”
Less than a year later, The Motley Fool hired full-time employees and opened offices in Alexandria, Virginia. The Gardners published the first of several New York Times bestsellers, The Motley Fool Investment Guide, in 1996.
Gardner said his subsequent career has been based on the idea that “everyone else is obsessed with ‘this number,’ [but] I think they’re missing something. Let’s go with this other thing.”
Gardner continued writing investment guides and books while recommending stocks years before they were popular, such as Amazon in 1997, Netflix in 2004 and Nvidia in 2005. He’s hosted a weekly edition of the “Rule Breaker Investing Podcast” since 2015 –– “no skips, no repeats” — and released what he said is his final stock-picking book, Rule Breaker Investing, in 2025.
The varied nature of Gardner’s business speaks not to a lack of focus but to his overall ethos: “In a largely goal-driven world, I realized I’m a purpose-driven person,” said Gardner.
Now, Gardner holds the title of “chief rule breaker” at The Motley Fool and described his current role as one of “thought leadership, voice leadership and cheer leadership.” He’s chair of The Motley Fool’s not-for-profit arm, the Fool Community Foundation, and champions its new Freedometer –– an interactive web-based tool created to help people get ahead financing and with investing.
“My company’s purpose, as stated to the world, is to make the world smarter, happier and richer,” he said. “And we always say at The Motley Fool, ‘Never one of those without the other two, never two without the third.’ When we’re at our best as a company, we’re making the world smarter and happier and richer, and that’s a world I want to live in.”
—Keenan Baker ’26