Navigate

University Weighs Dean Dome’s Fate

(UNC-Chapel Hill Photo/Ben McKeown)

The Dean E. Smith Center has been the basketball program’s tentpole for four decades, but its future remains unclear as University leaders weigh whether to renovate, rebuild or relocate the arena off campus. The latter possibility has unsurprisingly stoked fervent debate among students, alumni and administrators that Chancellor Lee Roberts said is “a good thing.”

“It shows the commitment of Carolina nation to Tar Heel basketball,” he told reporters after Thursday’s Board of Trustees meeting. “I’d be much more worried if people didn’t care.”

The existing arena has become burdened by outdated infrastructure and limited amenities, constraints exacerbated by the growing need for revenue generation in a new era of collegiate athletics. Further, the Smith Center’s proximity to the hospital creates parking and traffic issues, limiting its capacity for nonathletic revenue-generating events, such as concerts, the last of which was Boyz II Men in 2008.

Roberts has said the arena needs a new roof, more bathrooms, more concessions and significant improvements to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act, projects he estimates could cost up to $100 million without increasing the building’s potential to generate revenue.

“The advantage to Carolina North is you could build a new arena with modern amenities with premium seating, which would certainly help us on the revenue side,” Roberts told WRAL News in January. “Everyone’s trying to figure out how to generate more revenue. We could address this, and we could address the considerable traffic and parking issues that we have at the current Smith Center location.”

The athletic department said in a statement in December, “Careful study of arena options will help deliver a modern, basketball-first facility that enhances competitive excellence, strengthens recruiting and grows revenue to support Carolina Athletics. By improving fan experience, technology, accessibility and surrounding amenities, this process can ensure that the next generation of the Smith Center keeps Carolina Basketball an elite national program for decades to come.

Roberts added that amenities help spread out arrival times as fans arrive early to eat or have a drink, an approach which could reduce traffic. “And at a time when a lot of folks have a 4K television screen in their basement, you need to give them reasons to come to the game.”

Soon after Roberts became interim chancellor, in February 2024, the University confirmed it had commissioned a working group to explore whether to renovate the existing arena or construct a new one on or off campus. The group included representatives from the men’s and women’s basketball staffs, the Board of Trustees and the Rams Club. “Our goal is to create the best experience possible for Tar Heel student-athletes and fans while potentially generating more revenue for the Department and enhancing the University community,” the athletic department said in a statement when the commission was formed.

The physical master plan working group presented six options for the arena in August 2024: renovating the Smith Center; rebuilding it on its current site; or constructing a new arena in the adjacent Skipper Bowles Lot, at the now-demolished Odum Village site, at the Friday Center, or at Carolina North, a largely undeveloped tract the University owns. If it were moved off campus to the Friday Center or Carolina North, the University said it would provide busing for up to 3,000 students each game. By February 2025, multiple outlets reported that campus leaders were leaning toward building a new arena at Carolina North, where the Horace Williams Airport was located until it closed to general aviation traffic in 2018.

Roberts told reporters after the January Board of Trustees meeting the Smith Center’s fate involved three main factors: how the team can remain as competitive as possible, how students can be close to the court and how the fan experience can be enhanced.

His comments came days after former men’s basketball head coach Roy Williams ’72 (’73 MAT) publicly urged administrators to renovate the arena rather than relocate it. Williams won 241 of the 281 games he coached in the arena, which is named for his longtime mentor, Dean Smith, who coached the Heels from 1961 to 1997.

“I was Coach Smith’s assistant for 10 years,” Williams said in a video posted to social media Jan. 19. “We had many discussions about basketball, about life, about the golf course, everything, but I do know, during the conversations about what to get out of this building, the Smith Center, that Coach Smith wanted this place on campus.”

Williams said Smith told him it was Williams’ responsibility to fight to keep the basketball program on campus. Williams told Inside Carolina in February 2025, “If you go look at the picture of the groundbreaking of the Smith Center, of the 30 or 40 people there, there’s not too many others other than me still alive.”

Tyler Hansbrough ’09, who is the all-time leading scorer in Atlantic Coast Conference history, followed with a similar video Jan. 20, filmed on the steps outside the Smith Center. He said it was important to “keep the Smith Center right here on campus and push for renovations so many other Tar Heels can have the experience that we had right here in the future.”

The videos were posted across multiple platforms by The Committee for the Smith Center Renovation, whose website includes a petition to keep the Smith Center where it stands. The petition had garnered more than 21,000 signatures by Monday morning.

On Jan. 22, Roberts said of the videos, “One has his name on the court, and the other has his jersey hanging in the rafters and his name in the record books. So, their views deserve a lot of weight, perhaps more than most.”

The same day, the Board of Trustees approved the allocation of $8 million to begin planning the Carolina North campus, though the approval carried no provisions for a basketball arena. The previous night, students on the risers for the game against Notre Dame silently protested the arena’s potential relocation, holding up that morning’s issue of The Daily Tar Heel, the back cover of which displayed a full-page advertisement opposing the move and featured an image of Dean Smith on the court as well as the phrases “Students, Help Save The Smith Center” and “Keep Dean’s Legacy on Campus.”

The protest was organized by juniors John Harrison Kiger and Grant Sizemore, who handed out DTH copies to students near the court. Kiger later told the newspaper, “When you’re going through major decisions, you have to weigh in what the students think, because if the University isn’t here for us, then who’s it for?”

Head Coach Hubert Davis ’92, who played for Coach Smith as a student, told reporters after the Notre Dame game the Smith Center was “home,” but he loves “the leadership of Chancellor Roberts.” He has yet to take an official stance on the matter.

Several former players took to social media to voice their support for the Smith Center. Former forward Brice Johnson ’16, who played for Coach Williams, X, formerly Twitter, “It’s so sad being an alum at Carolina and hearing y’all reasons for moving … and it’s crazy to think other great programs didn’t even consider what y’all want us to do. … If you don’t understand the greatness of the house Dean built … you ain’t a Tar Heel! Period. Renovate Home.”

The Smith Center was the country’s third-largest on-campus arena when it opened in 1986, more than doubling the student seating that was available at Carmichael, though the majority of that extra seating was far from the court.

The Smith Center was privately funded to the tune of approximately $34 million. Any person who contributed more than $5,000 to the project secured a lower-level seat for life, and anyone who contributed more than $10,000 secured a seat for their child’s lifetime as well. According to Inside Carolina, there are at least 5,000 private seat licenses remaining from the original fundraising campaign, which legally limits what can be renovated in the arena.

Some alumni are in favor of relocating, such as Tom Stevens ’79 of Raleigh, who has been a season ticket holder since 2020. He said he rarely missed a basketball game at Carmichael Arena when he was a student.

He said, “like any good Tar Heel,” he reveres Roy Williams and Dean Smith, and like them, he wants the arena to remain on campus, but why not at the less-discussed Odum Village or Skipper Bowles Lot sites? And, he wondered,  couldn’t Carolina North feel like campus in a decade? Plans call for it to have student housing, classrooms and research buildings then.

No matter where the basketball program ends up, “the reality is students want a good product, and unfortunately, in this day and age, you have to have money to have a good product,” Stevens said. “If we have a good product, the students are gonna go, especially if they have good seats.”

The basketball program has won more than 500 games in the Smith Center, and today it seats 21,750 fans. Carolina had the highest average game attendance of any college basketball team in the country last year.

The University has been weighing the building’s fate for more than a decade. In 2013, it debuted concepts for a new arena built on the parking lot next to the Smith Center, though the project stalled as the University focused instead on building Karen Shelton Stadium, Dorrance Field, the Finley Track and Field Complex and the Bill Koman Indoor Practice Facility. The Smith Center was partially renovated in 2016, though the upgrades only affected locker rooms and the players’ lounge.

Joel Berry ’18, who was a starting guard at Carolina, told The News & Observer approximately 100 former players met via video conference in December with University officials who sought feedback on various options for the aging venue. The N&O reported multiple sources said the players were overwhelmingly in favor of keeping the Smith Center at its current site. University leaders have also met with donors and representatives from the Rams Club to hear feedback on the proposals.

Athletic Director Bubba Cunningham told The N&O, “I think the meetings we’ve had have been helpful to make sure we get it right. I think everybody wants what’s best for Carolina basketball, and you need an awful lot of input to be sure that you get it right.”

On Jan. 21, first-year forward Caleb Wilson told reporters the Smith Center, particularly its size and its legacy, was one of the main reasons he committed to Carolina. “It’s beautiful,” he said. “Even sometimes when I’m driving to practice or something like that, when I’m up on the hill, you look down and see the Smith Center, it’s just like, ‘Dang, that’s where I’m going to be playing at.’ ”

The University has not announced a timeline for the decision. Roberts told reporters Thursday, “There’s no perfect option.”

Share via: