Navigate

“Life’s Too Short for Boring Ice Cream”

In 2020, when the pandemic interrupted the global education program Maura McCarthy ’12 (’16 MA) was managing at N.C. State, she started making ice cream, first for herself and then for friends. Demand grew quickly, and the pursuit turned into a business, Bold Batch Creamery, and an identity. McCarthy adopted “Ice Cream Lady” as her LinkedIn headline, and she became “emotionally invested” in her growing menu of distinctive recipes. She’s as likely to add salt as sugar. She’ll mix in pears from her neighbor’s yard or biscuits from her oven. She uses dairy from Homeland Creamery in Julian and locally grown strawberries from Seal the Seasons, a farmer-first company Patrick Mateer ’15 launched from his dorm room. Bold Batch selections feature Trung Nguyen coffee, Monster Energy drinks and potato chips. There are vegan flavors, and then there is Bacon, Egg & Cheese ice cream.

“I can make everything with intention in a way that every single flavor is set apart,” McCarthy said. “If it says it’s this flavor, it should really taste like that flavor. If it has cookie dough, it should be really good cookie dough. I’m going to make it myself.”

During the pandemic, Maura McCarthy ’12 (’16 MA) started making ice cream for herself, then for friends. Now she runs Bold Batch Creamery, which sells unique flavors like grilled peach labneh at pop-up locations across Raleigh. (Photo: Carolina Alumni/Cory Dinkel)

For McCarthy, ice cream stirs creative expression and cultural capital. “It takes you somewhere,” she said. Every flavor in the Bold Batch collection is an entry into a culinary scrapbook. Get to know McCarthy’s ice cream, and you’ll get to know her. “Ice cream is just as much a blank canvas for personal expression as it is cultural expression,” she said. “There’s military brat culture, Southern culture, Raleigh culture, foodie culture and even artisan ice cream culture. Then, of course, there are cultures tied to places and people.”

Carolina crunch

Salted Kaya Toast is a duck-egg custard with coconut cream, palm sugar, pandan and caramelized milk bread crumb. McCarthy was inspired by a Singaporean breakfast dish.

The daughter of a Navy man, McCarthy was born in Tennessee. She attended elementary school in Florida and middle school in California. For high school, she lived in Tokyo, population about 30 million. In a blink, for her senior year, she moved to Richlands, population about 1,500. The itinerant childhood contributed to social anxiety, she said. It also taught her how to adapt.

“I really wanted to stay in Japan for my senior year,” she said. “We moved to North Carolina. Then, of course, that ended up being something really wonderful — getting to go to Carolina.”

During her first year in Hinton James, McCarthy did what she’d always done. She adapted. “I really looked at college as this fresh start for me and really taking care of myself. All my long walks from Hinton James were a good gateway into exercising more, feeling healthier,” McCarthy said.

Walking led to training for a half-marathon. She ran the Gimghoul Road loop and routes that expanded her sense of Chapel Hill. She joined UNC’s boxing club for the workouts. Running led to weight training. In her senior year, she took up powerlifting. Along the way, the Tennessee-Florida-California nomad, who at her Tokyo high school had worn a chef’s coat and learned to tourné root vegetables like a French entremetier, discovered something else: a love of Carolina hoops and a hatred for Duke.

“I felt it in my blood, and I’m not even from here,” she said. “I would get so mad. I think about it now, and I’m like, wow, there’s just something about the Carolina experience that makes you feel it genuinely.”

McCarthy majored in global studies with a minor in anthropology. Her senior year, in Cate Brubaker’s service-learning course, she found a passion for international education.

During the period McCarthy was at UNC, Brubaker taught a course that helped students find meaning in international experiences. To apply what they learned in class, students prepared and presented workshops to K-12 students at schools across the state. The course revealed a pathway back to Japan. She could teach there.

After college, McCarthy moved to Uwajima, a city of about 70,000, and helped Japanese teachers create lesson plans. She also facilitated a partnership with Chapel Hill High School to foster connections between students in Japan and Chapel Hill.

Biking from island to island, she visited community-run roadside stations with local produce, arts and crafts — and sofuto kurīmu, a Japanese soft-serve ice cream made from all sorts of local ingredients, from okra powder to scallops to persimmons. She tried them all.

“It’s so funny. I’ve always been an ice cream person, but back then I never, ever thought about making it,” McCarthy said.

Life’s impermanence

Sashay Sorbet is made with pink dragon fruit, passion fruit and lime. McCarthy recommends trying it topped with Tajin or serving it with your favorite sparkling beverage.

Back in the States, McCarthy returned to UNC for a master’s degree in international education and took a job at N.C. State as international programs coordinator. She managed exchange programs, advised students and supported faculty-led international courses. She felt the gratification she had imagined back in Brubaker’s course. “The students that went abroad, they came back as different people, not just because they picked up an accent that they really shouldn’t have,” she said. “They were better people in a lot of ways — better communicators, better listeners.”

Everything changed in March 2020. The quarantine left people isolated. McCarthy adapted. “I started teaching myself how to make ice cream for fun. Then, eventually I made it for friends and dropped it off at their houses because we couldn’t see each other.” Soon, strangers started contacting her, asking for ice cream. By August, she had rented production space.

As maddening as change can be, McCarthy understood the Japanese concept of mujō, which holds that everything is impermanent, and, as Ralph Waldo Emerson put it, everything we hold dear will melt away. What matters is how we grow from these experiences, how we prepare for the next thing.

For now, McCarthy does not run her own ice cream parlor. She sells scoops and treats at pop-up events across Raleigh, and Bold Batch pints are available at Sugar Euphoria, a Raleigh bakery owned by Randi Gordon Smith ’10.

“Whether you like it or not, you become more adaptable,” McCarthy said. “The whole thesis of my college experience is that people need to experience different things, and they need to move around. Otherwise, they’ll never be challenged, and they’ll never grow. I experienced that in high school. I experienced that growing up, moving every three years. I never would have grown if I hadn’t done that.”

— John Bare ’87 (’92 MA,’95 PhD)

Share via: