After living a lacrosse dream with her sisters, junior Chloe Humphrey is proving to be the next Tar Heel phenom.
by Tim Crothers ’86
Listen to this story as read by ElevenLabs AI.

Nicole Humphrey ’23 (’25 MAPS) , Ashley Humphrey ’25 (MAPS), & Chloe Humphrey (UNC Athletics)
Where does a national championship begin?
In this case, a yard. Specifically, a back yard. Like any yard, this one was just another random carpet of grass until it was trod on, chewed up, sweat and cried and even bled into, passed on, dodged on, shot on and inevitably scored on a bajillion times by three sisters.
This particular yard sits behind the Humphrey house on Three Wells Lane in Darien, Connecticut. Yes, Darien somehow got anointed by the lacrosse gods, an improbable place for lax immortality. Not unlike Chapel Hill.
The middle Humphrey sister, Ashley ’25 (MAPS), was the first to catch the lacrosse bug. Ashley possesses the creative brain of a point guard and preferred passing to shooting, so her older sister Nicole ’23 (’25 MAPS) eventually agreed to receive. The two would regularly practice in that Darien back yard until all of their yellow rubber lacrosse balls had been flung over the fence into the neighbor’s yard.
Meanwhile, her nose pressed against her bedroom window, baby sister Chloe observed it all with rapt attention. “I’d wait to hear the door shut when they came back inside, and then I’d go out in the yard and try to imitate what my sisters were doing,” Chloe said. “I would always be too embarrassed to try it in front of them, because I hated failure.” With her neon yellow-headed stick nearly as long as she was, Chloe, just 7 years old, would play wallball by herself until dark. Often later.
Nicole eventually joined a club team, and her coach showed up at the Humphrey house one summer day to give all three sisters a blueprint for success. “He was like our messiah who opened the gates to heaven,” Ashley said. “He saw potential in us, and he taught us the drills to be great. It was pure joy, never like, ‘Go outside and do 100 reps, and don’t come back in until you’re done.’ We were doing what we love with the people we love. It was poetic.”
Most every evening that summer of 2014, the girls would set up a speaker to play music while they practiced, sometimes in bare feet and bathing suits after a day at the pool. There was just one caveat. The three sisters quickly discovered that they were all too competitive to play against each other. So they played together. They only worked as teammates. The Humphrey sisters against the world.
Recognizing Chloe’s desire to practice past nightfall, the Humphrey parents, Sarah and John, fashioned Chloe’s own lacrosse laboratory in the garage, where their youngest daughter’s misfires dotted the walls with holes until netting was eventually installed. “My bedroom was right over the garage,” Nicole recalls. “There were lots of nights when I’d be about to fall asleep, and I’d hear bang bang bang, and I’d text my parents begging them to make Chloe stop.”

Ashley Humphrey ’25 (MAPS), left, set the NCAA single-season record for assists while playing for Stanford. She graduated in fall 2023 and transferred to UNC for the chance to play with Chloe during her freshman year. (UNC Athletics)
The sisters’ collective dream crystalized when they all watched the 2016 NCAA championship lacrosse game. Nicole was being recruited by UNC at the time, and the Tar Heels defeated Maryland 13–7. After that game, the three girls laid in the grass in their back yard, dreaming of winning one together at UNC. They dreamt about it even though it was impossible. Nicole and Chloe, after all, were separated by four grades in school. But childhood dreams don’t always have to make sense.
A few years later, when Chloe’s older sisters had both left for college, and John had replaced Ashley as her backyard practice partner, Chloe marched off 15 yards from the goal and then asked, “Dad, how many times do you think I can hit the crossbar in 10 shots?”
“Two?” John replied doubtfully.
“She did it five times,” John recalls, “and I was thinking, ‘Uh-oh, what do we have here?’ ”
A prodigy
Chloe was starstruck.
Attending her first UNC lacrosse summer camp staged at Greens Farms Academy in Westport, Connecticut, 10-year-old Chloe wandered around staring down at the turf when she bumped smack into Tar Heels coach Jenny Levy. “Are you looking for something?” Levy asked. Chloe could barely muster an answer. She mumbled that she’d lost her mouthguard. Chloe was mortified moments later to find it just below her chin, stuck in her sports bra.

Chloe Humphrey, center, would watch her older sisters practice outside at home and then go out by herself to imitate what they did. (UNC Athletics)
It was at that camp when Chloe first met Levy’s daughter, Kate. The two became fast friends. Kate shared Chloe’s ambition to play for the Tar Heels someday. “I remember Kate and me strutting around that camp decked out in all of our Carolina gear,” Chloe said laughing at the memory. “It’s like we were pretending we were UNC commits. I was still in sixth grade!”
Jenny Levy’s memory of her initial contact with Humphrey is a bit different. The UNC coach recalls one morning at that Greens Farms camp when Levy’s eyes were drawn to this little child performing stick tricks that some of her college players couldn’t do. “The kid was teeny, but her skill was miles beyond anything that I’d ever seen in a player her age,” Levy said. “I remember asking, ‘Who’s that?’ Everyone said, ‘Oh, that’s Chloe.’ It was just Chloe. One name. Like Mia. Chloe.”
Levy was starstruck.
The mentor
The GOAT and the kid first met in August 2023. Erin and Chloe. A few weeks into Chloe’s first year at UNC, Coach Levy asked her to meet with Tar Heel legend Erin Matson ’23. Said Levy, “I told Chloe, ‘Hey, I need you to talk to Erin. She’s the field hockey version of you.’ ”
Levy was matchmaking greatness.
“I still remember the first time I saw Erin play in her freshman year at UNC,” said Levy, who played lacrosse and field hockey at Virginia. “I was like, ‘Holy cow, that’s the most incredible field hockey player I’ve ever seen.’ It just looks like she’s floating out there. Everything about her play was electric. I feel the exact same way about Chloe. Chloe doesn’t know yet how great she is, but I believe she will go down in history as the best to ever play our sport.”

Nicole Humphrey ’23 (’25 MAPS), right, transferred from UNC to the University of Southern California, but came back to play at Carolina after an injury sidelined her final season at USC. (UNC Athletics)
History suggests that Erin and Chloe are cut from the same cloth. Erin scored the game-winning goal with 1:19 left in her final college game to clinch a championship and an undefeated season. Six months later, Chloe scored the game-winning goal with 1:13 left in her final high school game to clinch a championship and an undefeated season.
So on that August day in 2023, the legend and the soon-to-be legend strolled the red bricks of UNC’s campus together, one a dynasty builder, the other imagining her own. They laughed about how driven (or is it obsessed? addicted?) they both are, one incubated in a Connecticut garage, the other a Pennsylvania basement. “I told Erin I was in awe of her accomplishments,” Chloe recalls. “I remember she said, ‘I’ve heard you’re pretty good yourself.’ That gave me goosebumps.”
“There was a lot of respect from both of us because I could immediately tell the way her mind works is very similar to mine,” said Matson, now UNC’s national championship field hockey coach. “Chloe’s different. She has that it factor. That edge. Being around Chloe felt a little like looking in the mirror.” (See “They Don’t Have an Answer for Her,” May/June 2020 Review.)
They eventually wound up at the UNC field hockey office, where Erin showed Chloe the four national championship trophies she and her teammates had recently added to the display case. As the two young women stared at the hardware, Erin told Chloe how hearing stories of Mia Hamm ’94 winning four nattys before her inspired Matson to believe it was possible. “I’ve always set these crazy goals for my lacrosse career, and most people look at me like I have three heads,” Chloe said. “That day it felt like Erin gave me permission to shoot for the moon.”
The perfect storm
The coaches thought her tracker must be broken. At the end of a practice early in Chloe’s first season at UNC, the device measured her energy output at 50 percent more than anybody else on the team. They tried a different tracker. It wasn’t a mistake. “It’s a family joke that I have raging ADHD,” Chloe said. “I’m wired differently. I can’t stand around and be OK with not getting better in that second, which I know makes me sound like a crazy person. Thinking about somebody else working harder than me makes me cringe, but my biggest strength is also my biggest weakness because that leads to injury.”
Indeed, Chloe’s first season at UNC wasn’t actually her first season at UNC. She missed all of 2024 with a stress reaction in her foot. (Overuse injuries also forced her to sit out games at Darien High.) The only opponent ever to stop Chloe is Chloe.
UNC women’s lacrosse head coach Jenny Levy recalls one morning at a camp when her eyes were drawn to a little child performing stick tricks that some of her college players couldn’t do. “The kid was teeny, but her skill was miles beyond anything that I’d ever seen in a player her age,” Levy said. “I remember asking, ‘Who’s that?’ Everyone said, ‘Oh, that’s Chloe.’ It was just Chloe. One name. Like Mia. Chloe.”
The Tar Heels lost eight critical players to injury in 2024 and finished with a 10–7 record, the program’s worst in two decades. Chloe chafed on the sideline, her foot in a walking boot. “I looked at our bench sometimes and thought, ‘We’re pretty sad right now,’ ” Levy remembers. “It’s not that the kids on the field weren’t talented, we were just missing something, like the yin without the yang.” The yang, of course, was Chloe.
Yet, from those ashes sprouted the Humphrey sisters’ decade-old UNC dream. Perhaps the three of them playing together wasn’t impossible after all, but their reunion is no routine fairy tale. Just two years ago, at the close of the 2023 spring semester, none of the three Humphrey sisters was even on the Tar Heels roster. Nicole had just transferred from UNC to the University of Southern California for her final season. Ashley was playing for Stanford University, and Chloe had just finished playing in that high school state title game in Darien as the nation’s top-ranked recruit.
After two stellar seasons in Palo Alto, which included setting the NCAA single-season record for assists, Ashley graduated in fall 2023 and transferred to UNC for the chance to play with Chloe during her freshman year. Like Chloe, Nicole also injured her foot that fall. “I remember sitting in my room at USC thinking that I’m out for the season,” Nicole said, “and how that was clearly meant to happen and how I’m supposed to return to UNC and play with both of my sisters for the first time ever. It was destiny.”

At the end of a practice early in her first UNC season, Chloe Humphrey’s coaches thought her activity tracker must be broken. The device measured her energy output at 50 percent more than anybody else on the team. They tried a different tracker. It wasn’t a mistake. (UNC Athletics)
Back in Chapel Hill, Nicole reclaimed her No. 9 jersey from Chloe, who switched back to the No. 2 she’d worn in high school. Ashley wore No. 18. (9 x 2 = 18. Three elements of the same equation, as always.)
UNC began the 2025 season with a roster that included seven grad students and nine first-years. “We were like this island of misfit toys trying to do something very special,” Ashley said.
“It felt like a brand-new team,” Levy said. “They played with the freedom and fearlessness of a group that had no idea how good they could be. We were just gritty, tough dogs.”
Recovered from her foot injury, Chloe quickly established herself as the top dog. Continuing a tradition she began as a high school senior, Chloe created a checklist in her phone’s notes app that listed each opponent on UNC’s schedule. “It’s like my to-do list,” Chloe said. “I have to get the job done in all of those games. I don’t know what I’d do if I ever lost, because I really need to check it off.” (Spoiler alert: Chloe hasn’t lost a lacrosse game since her high school state championship in 2022, and she admitted, “I still think about that game every day!”)
This past season Chloe broke UNC’s single-season record with 90 goals, including 30 fed directly from Ashley, who broke her own NCAA record for assists in a season. (Nicole, still not fully healthy, scored six goals in a reserve midfield role.)
“Chloe can beat you in so many different ways,” Levy said. “Whether it’s right, left, high, low, off ball, with ball, feeding, her passion to ride and tackle back. She scores goals despite getting double-teamed and face-guarded and hit all sorts of ways to try to dismantle her.”
The 5-foot-4-inch wunderkind scored at least a hat trick in 18 of UNC’s 22 matches and never fewer than two goals in any game. “It’s like Chloe lives out the Wayne Gretzky quote that she doesn’t want someone to come to one of her games and walk away saying, ‘Yeah, she was OK,’ ” John said. “She also mimics Michael Jordan [’86] in that if someone says, ‘Yeah, I played against her, and she wasn’t all that,’ the next time they play, Look out!”
A student of Matson’s press conferences on YouTube, Chloe tries her best to deflect the spotlight toward her sisters and other teammates, but her highlight reel undermines her.
“All season Chloe had these moments when our whole team would say, ‘Oh my god, how did she just do that?!’ ” Ashley said. “One of the reasons Chloe is so hard to defend is that even she doesn’t know what she’s going to do next.”
An undefeated dream season
It was time for her Matson Moment. With UNC trailing 4–2 after the first quarter in the NCAA semifinal against the University of Florida, Chloe joined a quick huddle on the Tar Heel sideline with just Ashley and Nicole. Nicole turned to Chloe and delivered a hard truth: ‘We’re not going to win this game with you playing scared.”
“I know,” Chloe said.

With UNC trailing 4–2 after the first quarter in the NCAA semifinal against the University of Florida, Chloe joined a quick huddle on the Tar Heel sideline with just Ashley and Nicole. “It’s just another game,” Nicole told them both. “It’s like playing in the back yard.” (UNC Athletics)
Then a more maternal message. “It’s just another game,” Nicole told them both. “It’s like playing in the back yard.”
Chloe nodded dutifully like the baby sister she is. “That clicked me in,” she said. “My whole life I tend to play my best at times when the most is on the line, and I absolutely hate to lose. I play to not feel that way. So I just remember looking up at the scoreboard and thinking, ‘OK, just get me the ball!’ ”
As Levy put it, “Chloe went amazingly ballistic.”
In a span of just 3 minutes and 11 seconds early in the second quarter, Chloe scored three goals to push UNC ahead 5–4. “She’s the fiercest competitor I’ve ever played with,” Ashley said. “She got that look in her eye, and it’s like ‘Uh-oh, nobody’s going to stop her.’ It’s the Chloe Effect. She can always find another gear that nobody else has.”
The Chloe Effect ignited a barrage of 18 straight Tar Heel goals in the game, highlighted by a career-best seven from Chloe. Florida never scored again against UNC’s self-proclaimed “velociraptor defense.” Ashley’s four assists broke UNC’s season points record, and Nicole came off the bench to score UNC’s final goal in the 20–4 win.
After the game, Chloe received a text from Matson: You’re insane. Full psycho. Love it.
Chloe: Hahaha thank you LFG
Matson: F*** yeah sis GO GET IT
On the cusp of her first national championship, Chloe relished having yet another sister in her huddle.
In UNC’s 12–8 victory over Northwestern University in the NCAA final, Chloe scored four more goals, and her old camp friend Kate Levy, now a sophomore at Carolina, produced the goal that put the Tar Heels ahead to stay. After completing their undefeated dream season, the Humphrey sisters sought each other out, all three tearing up in a joyous embrace. It was poetic.

Photo by Jamie Schwaberow/UNC Athletic Communications
“I had a quick flashback to those summers in the yard when we’d be sitting in the grass thinking how cool it would be to win a championship together,” Chloe said. “And there we were. It was a full circle moment. Fate brought the Humphrey sisters their national championship.”
“I immediately sensed from Chloe that she was like, ‘OK, what’s next?’ ” Levy said. “She wants to win four. She wants to do things with this program that we’ve never done here.” (Four days after winning the national title, Chloe became the first-ever Tar Heel to receive the Tewaaraton Award as the nation’s top lacrosse player.)
Within minutes of raising the championship trophy, much like Matson always did, Chloe admits she was already thinking ahead about how to get another one. “My parents were like, ‘This is what you’ve always dreamed of, can’t you just be happy in the moment?’ ” Chloe said. “I just laughed. They know I’m not going to listen. My mantra has always been, There’s more to come.”
So, where does another national championship begin?
When Chloe arrived back home in Darien after checking off the natty on her to-do list, the first thing she did was grab her lacrosse stick and walk through the house on Three Wells Lane, through the garage pocked with holes and through the kitchen where three NCAA championship trophies sat side-by-side on the counter. Nicole and Ashley weren’t there, just as Chloe knew they wouldn’t be next season at Dorrance Field. But Gretzky and Jordan and Mia and Erin were all there. So Chloe marched straight out to the back yard to play wallball.
Uh-oh.
Tim Crothers ’86 is a former senior writer for Sports Illustrated and teaches writing at the UNC Hussman School of Journalism and Media.
Carolina Alumni members, sign in to continue reading.
Not yet a member? Become one today.