Navigate

Turtle Umwelt

Late one summer night in 1993 while working alone on campus, sea turtle researcher Cathy Lohmann had a eureka moment. The assistant teaching professor in biology and her biology professor husband, Ken Lohmann, had already made one earthshaking discovery two years earlier — that loggerhead and green sea turtles have an internal biological compass and could tell north from south.

Until then no one knew how the turtles migrated. After hatching on southeastern U.S. beaches, they plunged into the North Atlantic gyre, the clockwise current that runs between North America and Europe, and somehow females found their way back 20 or 30 years later to lay eggs. (No one knows how long sea turtles live. At least 60 or 70 years is the best estimate.)

Now, while poring over strange data from their most recent experiment, she realized they had their first evidence another breakthrough was close — that sea turtles also use the Earth’s geomagnetic field like a low-resolution GPS system. The turtles navigated with built-in compasses and maps, innate navigation systems that teamed up to make their 10,000-mile odyssey possible.

“I was so excited,” Cathy recalled. “I put everything away and drove home, and Ken had fallen asleep, and I wanted to wake him up and say, ‘Hey, I think I figured it out.’ ”

Internal GPS

Cathy and Ken have worked together for more than 30 years, ever since they met as graduate students at the University of Florida. But their story starts years earlier when Ken was growing up in West Lafayette, Indiana — “as far from the ocean as you can get,” he joked. As a boy, the natural world beguiled him, especially unusual animals such as the starfish he saw on family vacations. Most of all, he was captivated by the mystery of how monarch butterflies make their annual 3,000-mile trek. “I’ve always had a fascination with animals that migrate long distances,” he said.

As a newly minted PhD at 29, he thought how turtles migrated was obvious — they must have a magnetic sense, he surmised. So strong was his youthful enthusiasm that he presumed he would unravel every migration riddle in two years.

Instead, teasing out the secrets of sea turtle migration evolved into a lifelong pursuit. In 2023, the International Sea Turtle Society honored him with its Lifetime Achievement Award. Ken has coauthored more than 100 scholarly papers on sea turtle migration, and he and Cathy have published more than two dozen together.

Ken believes young turtles also inherit instructions that tell them what to do when they encounter various magnetic fields on their migratory path. “That was a really surprising finding,” he said. “We didn’t anticipate that. It looks like that’s their trick for completing their migration. They inherit responses and instinctively know what to do.”

Every August the Lohmanns bring 16 cookie-sized hatchlings to their lab. The pair receive permissions to capture the turtles from state, University and government groups, including North Carolina, UNC’s Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service. All are returned to the Atlantic after a few months. Each turtle swims in its own suitcase-sized tank with a Carolina blue rim. The turtles, which grow to be a foot long while in captivity, are marked on different segments of their shells with nail polish to identify them. Last year’s naming theme was cheese. So, Philly Cream, Brie, Goat, Cheddar and Mozzarella (who likes to leave his food and pick at it) were among the test subjects.

Ken’s scholarly trek has been aided by his knack for conjuring up ingenious experiments — “bomb-proof” he calls them — that cut to the heart of scientific mysteries. Michael Salmon, Ken’s postdoc adviser, calls Ken and Cathy “brilliant.”

“They are as close to being perfect scientists as I’ve ever seen,” said Salmon, a Florida Atlantic University biology professor. “They write experiments designed to be decisive. They find the perfect way to demonstrate something experimentally.”

Research scientist Nathan Putman ’11 PhD) described Ken as “very thoughtful, methodical and meticulous. ‘Ponder’ is a word he often used. He’s achieved a lot of really fantastic science from all that pondering.” Ken was Putman’s PhD adviser, and Putman and Ken have now collaborated on a half-dozen papers.

Back in the lab, a hatchling loggerhead diligently swims. Power stroking with dog-paddle movements, it lifts its head to breathe before getting back to work. But this turtle is suspended in air — not water. It dangles in a cozy neoprene harness that hangs below a bar linked to a motor that rotates it in a circle, mimicking steady wave motion. The purpose? With all other external stimuli removed, it proves hatchlings only steer relative to wave motion whose steady direction helps them begin their northern odyssey.

Another experiment creates a virtual-reality environment. Turtles tethered to a tracking arm in a pool can swim in any direction, but they are inside an 8-by-8-foot electromagnetic “cage.” Wires coiled around the spartan wooden frame of the water tank can shift the magnetic field in the pool to duplicate any spot in the Atlantic Ocean. Change the field, and the turtles change course.

How precisely do they navigate? “They’re capable of figuring out the difference between North and South Carolina,” Cathy said. “They don’t always go back to the same place and adjust to different situations like, ‘Oh, there’s been a storm. My beach doesn’t exist anymore. I’ll find a new one.’ ”

Magnetic mystery

With only five senses, humans don’t know what they’re missing. Sharks sniff electrical impulses. Snakes see ultraviolet light. Catfish taste with whiskers.

“Every animal has its own way of sensing the world, its own umwelt,” said Ed Yong, author of An Immense World: How Animal Senses Reveal the Hidden Realms Around Us. “They show us that our way of experiencing the world is limited. It forces us to stretch our imaginations in a new, powerful way that enriches our understanding of the world.”

Magnetoreception is not limited to turtles. Animals as varied as brown bats, salamanders, mole rats, nightingales and lobsters share the ability. It is the last sensory system to defy scientists; no one knows how turtles process signals from Earth’s magnetic field.

But the Lohmanns think they’re getting closer to solving this puzzle. Turtles have two different magnetic senses, according to their latest research. One helps them distinguish between north and south. The other learns and remembers magnetic fields associated with different locations so they can return to those places in the same way that humans drop “pins” in their phones to help them navigate. Two types of microscopic magnetoreceptors are likely in a part or parts of turtles’ brains, and each governs a different sort of navigation, according to Ken. One type contains magnetite, a mineral found in other animals that perceive magnetic fields. Trout, for example, have it in their snouts. “Turtles may have a system of little sensors that are basically tiny bar magnets or compass needles in their brains,” he said.

“We’re trying to figure out as the first step what parts of the brain turn on and off when they experience changes in the magnetic field,” Cathy added. “We’ve got some work to do on that.”

In addition, chemical magnetoreception, a process in which molecules trade electrons, is likely the mechanism behind the other navigation system. “It’s conceivable that sea turtles can see the Earth’s magnetic field. There’s no evidence in favor of that or against that, either,” Cathy said. “It’s a fun idea.”

Whatever the final answer turns out to be, the Lohmanns are convinced that nature and nurture share roles in sea turtles’ seafaring wizardry. Their slow and steady research now involves figuring out what part, or parts, of a turtle’s brain turns on or off when the animal’s magnetic field shifts.

Anyone who uses GPS to find the Lohmanns’ home will know they have come to the correct place. A large turtle statue in their front yard greets all guests.

“Sea turtles are astonishing,” Cathy said. “The babies are so small, so helpless and so cute. But when you see a big adult female on the beach nesting, you feel you’re associating with something primordial, something fundamental about life. She’s there to lay eggs. She’s got a plan. It’s life pushing her forward, and it strikes you. It’s moving.”

— George Spencer

Share via: