Prep Football Brain Injuries Appear to Be Rising

Catastrophic brain injuries associated with full-contact football appear to be rising, especially among high school students. The increase is alarming and indicates more coaches and athletic trainers should change how they teach the fundamental skills of the game, according to researchers based at UNC.

Until recently, the number of football-related brain injuries with permanent disability in high school had remained in the single digits since 1984. However, the tally rose to 10 injuries in 2008 and 2009, and there were 13 in 2011, according to the latest catastrophic football injury research annual report from the UNC-based National Center for Catastrophic Sports Injury Research.

“These 2011 numbers are the highest since we began collecting catastrophic brain injury data,” said Fred Mueller ’61 (’64 MEd, ’70 PhD), the report’s lead author, director of the center and professor emeritus of exercise and sports science. “This is a major problem.”

About 4.2 million football players compete nationwide, including 1.1 million high schoolers.

The center has collected data and published annual reports on catastrophic football injuries, including fatalities, disabilities and serious injuries, for 48 years. The National Collegiate Athletic Association, National Federation of State High School Associations and the American Football Coaches Association fund the research.

The center’s work has played a role in nearly eliminating football fatalities, as well as dramatically reducing the number of cervical cord injuries to single digits, between the late 1960s and the early 1990s.

Since 1977, about 67 percent of football-related catastrophic injuries have been suffered by players as they made tackles. Mueller said part of the problem is that despite being prohibited in 1976, head-to-head contact — such as butt-blocking, face tackling or spearing tackles — is still occurring. These strategies make the head the initial and primary contact point with an opposing player and often lead to cervical spine fractures or permanent brain injuries.

Some players recover fully after surgery and rehabilitation following injuries. However, many only recover partially, living with paralysis or mental deficiency, relying on intensive lifetime medical care. Since 1984, there have been 488 cervical cord and cerebral injuries with incomplete recovery, including 164 brain injuries, of which 148 were among high-schoolers. Additionally, the years between 2001 to 2010 saw a 25 percent jump in football-related disability brain injuries over the previous decade, increasing to 66 from 52 incidents among all types of players.

Other potential reasons for the apparent increase in brain injuries may be because of heightened awareness of the issue. Also, this year’s report updated the number of football participants. However, Mueller noted that neither of these factors likely influenced the overall figures, since the report’s definition of catastrophic injuries (defined as injuries that resulted in brain or spinal cord injury or skull or spine fracture, which involved some disability at the time of the accident) and data collection methods have remained unchanged.

Mueller said reversing the trend would require several changes, which some in the football community already are implementing. Coaches must be well-versed in the signs and symptoms of concussions, such as headaches, dizziness, nausea and light sensitivity, and pull players from games if they exhibit those indicators. Players should not return to play until cleared by a physician. Teams also should hold preseason meetings to discuss concussions, conduct medical evaluations of all players and emphasize that the head should not be used in tackling or blocking.

The report’s recommendations also note that schools should hire coaches who teach proper fundamental skills, and retain athletic trainers certified by the National Athletic Trainers’ Association. Referees must be vigilant about throwing flags when they see illegal tackles, and parents also must be involved in meetings and discussions about concussions.

“All of these measures are important if we want to continue to make a positive impact on the game,” he said. “We have to continue research in this area. Accurate data not only indicate problem spots, but they also help us offer appropriate precautions and reveal the adequacy of our preventive measures.”

More online…

  • Concussion Researcher Named MacArthur Fellow
    News report from September 2011
  • UNC Hosting Program Highlighting Concussions
    News report fromm January 2011
  • High-Tech Helmets Show Impact of Hits to the Head
    News report from December 2007
  • Born of Tragedy, A Pioneer for Players: How sports medicine has evolved at Carolina.
    From the November/December 2005 issue of the Carolina Alumni Review, available online to GAA members.
  • The Dark Aftermath of Glory: Retired athletes often limp off the field. Kevin Guskiewicz is trying to help — and maybe change the way active players are treated. From the May/June 2004 issue of the Carolina Alumni Review, available online to GAA members.
  • Making Sports Safer: With the intent of taking the guesswork out of deciding when athletes with head injuries can safely resume playing, then-assistant professor Kevin Guskiewicz received an $84,000, two-year grant to study the effects of mild head injuries on athletes’ balance and mental functions such as attention span, memory and concentration. From the November/December 1996 issue of the Carolina Alumni Review, available online to GAA members.

Share via: